Skip to main content
ICML The Archive

Veterans Register

Asking Congress to undo a discharge

For more than a century, soldiers and sailors discharged without honor, or their widows and mothers, had one place to turn. They asked Congress to pass a law in their own name, correcting what the Army or the Navy would not. These are their cases, each told from the official record and linked to the reports that record it.

NameServedServiceWhy dischargedBefore CongressOutcome
Ned AndersonAutomatic dishonor when enlistment expired during confinement although the court-martial sentence imposed no discharge1930Committee recommended relief
John M. Andrewsalso recorded as John Douglas, John Douglass, Harry K. Bruce1897–1919ArmyThirty days in a city jail for a street fight in Columbus, Ohio1925–1928Relief enacted
John F. AntlitzPhysical disability wrongly deemed preexisting and therefore treated as fraudulent enlistment under Army Regulations 1386 and 1511900–1902Relief enacted
George W. BakerSurgeon’s certificate of disability attributing tertiary syphilis to a pre-service infection and classifying the condition as not in line of duty1934Never enacted
Walter BakerFraudulent enlistment based solely on concealment of minority after Baker enlisted at age 17 and his mother later requested his release1924Committee recommended relief
Wade W. BarberDischarge without honor for a minor age overstatement at enlistment1926Committee recommended relief
Thomas M. Bardin1891–1896ArmyStill serving a three-month guardhouse sentence on the day his five-year enlistment ended1934–1935Vetoed
Thomas Barrett1898–1900ArmyA company commander’s statement that he had become “morally and physically unfit” through his own fault1928–1931Relief enacted
Henry A. BehrensAdministratively substituted after the War Department admitted that the general court-martial lacked jurisdiction and its dishonorable-disch1937Relief enacted
William K. Beldin1923–1925Army (earlier Navy)Hiding a Navy dishonorable discharge that the Navy itself later replaced with an honorable one1932–1935Never enacted
Charles W. Bendure1899–1902ArmyEnlistment expired while he served a court-martial sentence that did not include discharge1928–1930Never enacted
Erney S. Blazer1899–1902ArmyHis enlistment ended while he was confined under a sentence that did not include discharge1932–1934Relief enacted
Levin W. BothumEntire Company A, First Eastern Shore Maryland Infantry, retroactively deemed discharged without honor in 1896 for refusing orders in 1862; 1902Committee recommended relief
William P. BradySecret internal discharge-without-honor status contradicted by the favorable certificate delivered to him1929–1930Committee recommended relief
Harrison Brainard, alias Harry WhiteEnlistment under an assumed name; discharged for false pretenses despite apparently satisfactory service and no complaint against his Army r1935Never enacted
William L. BruhnAlleged fraudulent enlistment for enlisting as a single man while married, although Bruhn stated recruiters never asked his marital status1930Committee recommended relief
William G. BurressSurgeon’s certificate of disability for disease deemed not incident to service; evidence instead identified muscular rheumatism, exposure du1931–1934Committee recommended relief
Thomas CarrollEnlistment expired while serving a 90-day hard-labor sentence imposed by summary court six days before expiration; Army Regulation paragraph1930Committee recommended relief
Richard A. ChavisAdministratively deemed discharged without honor when his volunteer company mustered out while he was absent without leave, after he had com1930–1934Committee recommended relief
Harry Cinq-Mars1891–1899ArmyA board of officers found his character bad after a court-martial acquitted him1928–1932Never enacted
James William ColeAdministrative discharge without honor added beyond minor punishment adjudged by court-martial1926–1930Never enacted
William Connelly, alias William E. Connoley (also William Connell/Conley)Enlisted as a minor without parental consent and concealed his minority; discharged for enlistment under false pretenses after his parents r1936Committee recommended relief
Jacob M. CooperUnderage enlistment without parental consent; Army treated his statement that he was 18 as fraudulent concealment of age1913Relief enacted
Edward T. Costello1901–1914ArmyImprisoned under a police court sentence during his fifth enlistment1931–1934Never enacted
James Albert Couch (alias Albert Couch; later James A. Couch)General court-martial convicted Couch of disobeying reserve-patrol orders while the town faced enemy attack and fraudulent underage enlistme1930Relief enacted
Thomas A. CoyneCivil conviction and imprisonment produced a separation under other than honorable conditions; Coyne later reenlisted and completed service 1934–1936Committee recommended relief
Fay A. CushmanFraudulent enlistment based on marrying later the same day he enlisted after stating that he was unmarried1935Never enacted
John P. DaleyDischarge without honor based on a demonstrably false allegation that he concealed a wife and dependents1926Relief enacted
James Darcy, Alias James HurleyYouthful fraudulent enlistment followed by later honorable service1934Never enacted
Leonard L. DilgerEnlisted at age 19½ without parental consent while correctly stating his age; discharged for enlistment under false pretenses after his pare1932–1934Committee recommended relief
Seymour H. Dotson (alias William Dodson)Acceptance of discharge without honor to obtain transportation home instead of remaining overseas for trial1931Committee recommended relief
Everett A. DoughertyDesertion after difficulty performing unfamiliar Hospital Corps duties and alleged advice from a hospital steward that leaving would be easi1929Relief enacted
Thomas Dowling, alias James MurphyEarlier discharge without honor that survived eighteen years of later honorable service1926Committee recommended relief
Martin L. DuffyUnderage enlistment under an overstated age, followed by a parental request for discharge based on minority1926–1928Committee recommended relief
Albert P. Dunbar1898ArmyA venereal disease the Army counted as his own fault1932–1945Never enacted
William J. DunlapUnauthorized discharge without honor issued contrary to an order recognizing mental irresponsibility1926Committee recommended relief
William S. DunnImprisoned in Wisconsin state prison when his volunteer regiment mustered out after a civilian conviction for assault with attempted highway1904Committee recommended relief
John G. DwyerGeneral court-martial conviction for criminal negligence based on alleged failure to examine and treat a soldier who was examined by Dwyer’s1932Committee recommended relief
Walter Elkan (alias Walter Eckhardt)Failure to comply with an order of his company commander and absence from drill1905Committee recommended relief
Oliver EllisonAdministrative discharge without honor after summary convictions, without a general court-martial discharge sentence1929–1930Committee recommended relief
George Evans1901–1902Army“For the good of the service,” with no offense named1926–1931Never enacted
Aaron S. Fass1898–1899ArmyA board’s finding of service “not honest and faithful” after small fines for minor offenses1929–1934Never enacted
Harry FlaneryGeneral court-martial imposed six months’ confinement and forfeiture of $10 per month, but no discharge; because the sentence extended beyon1933Never enacted
William H. FlemingSubstituted after the War Department declared his general court-martial illegally constituted and its dishonorable-discharge sentence void; 1929–1930Committee recommended relief
Joseph Franklinalso recorded as Joseph Benjamin Franklin1898–1899ArmyEnlisted at seventeen on a consent letter he wrote himself, and was discharged when his parents asked1926–1931Never enacted
Lowell G. Fuller1889–1899ArmyEnlisting in 1899 without disclosing an 1890 desertion for which he held a deserter’s release1928–1931Relief enacted
Francis GerrityAutomatic discharge without honor following a civilian conviction and imprisonment1934–1939Never enacted
Abram L. Gersonalso recorded as Abe A. Gerson1898ArmyDisability from a disease the Army called “not incident to the service”1930–1941Never enacted
Harvey H. Goyer1902 force-reduction discharge without honor resting on an unexplained character conclusion1929–1930Never enacted
Peter HaanVoid general court-martial sentence because the court was illegally constituted; administrative discharge without honor substituted while he1937Committee recommended relief
Theodore J. Hillmanalso recorded as T. J. Hillman1898ArmyMissed two roll calls after coming home sick from Cuba1929–1930Relief enacted
Turpin G. HovasAutomatic discharge without honor because confinement extended beyond expiration of enlistment1926Committee recommended relief
Frank P. HoytInitial disability discharge without honor; later fraudulent-enlistment conviction for concealing that discharge when reenlisting1939Vetoed
James A. HughesPsychosis and prior desertion; after voluntary surrender and restoration to duty without trial, civil commitment made return to military ser1924–1926Relief enacted
Judson B. Isbester, alias James E. DolanMandatory discharge without honor after a civilian conviction despite medical circumstances and later excellent service1934Committee recommended relief
Paul Jelna1902 force-reduction discharge without honor based on discretionary local selection1930–1934Relief enacted
Curtis Jett1898ArmyAn Army surgeon’s finding of a disease “not in line of duty,” which he disputed1932–1939Never enacted
Thomas JohnsenFraudulent enlistment for representing himself as single, followed by reconciliation with his pregnant wife1928Committee recommended relief
Peter S. KellyOriginal dishonorable-discharge sentence was void because the general court-martial was illegally constituted and lacked jurisdiction; Army 1928Committee recommended relief
William Laws1863–1865ArmyMustered out while serving a court-martial sentence that did not include discharge1927–1936Vetoed
Edward R. Ledwell1898–1902ArmyHis third enlistment papers left out his first enlistment1924–1926Relief enacted
William Frank Lippsalso recorded as William F. Lipps1901–1904ArmyA $5 civil fine, and the jail term he was given for not paying it1935–1937Vetoed
Charles E. Lowe1899–1900ArmyAn Army board’s finding that he shot his own hand on purpose, which the two men present swore was an accident1925–1928Relief enacted
Jeremiah F. MahoneyFraudulent-enlistment charges arising from reenlistment during the Spanish-American War after a prior disability discharge, although recruit1927–1930Relief enacted
Alling R. Maish1898–1902, 1918–1920ArmyDeserted after the Army refused to release him for his aged father’s sake1926Relief enacted
Michael Marley1902 mass-reduction discharge without honor imposed without meaningful notice1930–1932Committee recommended relief
James J. McBarnes1902 mass-reduction discharge without honor not adjudged by court-martial1931Never enacted
Christopher C. McCammentMedical discharge under Army Regulations after Army physicians diagnosed tertiary syphilis and recorded McCamment’s admission of an earlier 1912Relief denied
Fred McGarrahanUnauthorized discharge without honor despite the absence of regulatory authority1940Never enacted
Thomas A. McGurk (earlier used Thomas Devlin)Four general court-martial dishonorable discharges during repeated early enlistments, and a later discharge without honor following a conviction1929–1935Committee recommended relief
James McKinsey (report title: James McKenzie)Desertion from first Civil War enlistment; while still carried as a deserter, reenlisted under the McKenzie spelling and later completed tha1903–1910Relief enacted
Andrew McLaughlinFirst discharge, court-martial conviction for desertion after a five-day absence to visit his mother followed by voluntary surrender; second1927Relief enacted
Edward R. McOmberMedical discharge on a surgeon’s certificate for disability and disease deemed not incurred in line of duty1929–1930Never enacted
William S. McWilliamsFraudulent enlistment based on concealing rheumatism and asthma when reenlisting, although the conditions had been contracted in line of dut1929–1930Committee recommended relief
James J. Meaney1902 force-reduction discharge without honor despite illness and no recorded misconduct1932–1933Relief enacted
Alfred G. V. Meldahlalso recorded as Alfred Gustav Valdemar Meldahl1899–1902ArmyA board’s finding that his service was not honest and faithful, during the 1902 reduction of the Army1927–1930Never enacted
George ModranDischarged as an alien enemy because he was Austrian-born, pursuant to War Department instructions of January 27, 1918, despite voluntary pr1935Never enacted
William M. Moore / Mary MooreUnexplained discharge without honor for which the War Department could find no factual basis1926–1927Committee recommended relief
William MoseleyConfinement awaiting trial on a perjury charge arising from prosecution eyewitness testimony; never tried before the unit mustered out1938Relief enacted
James E. Moyer1902 Army force-reduction order in the Philippines; discharge imposed on the company commander’s unsupported character judgment despite no c1927–1928Relief enacted
Robert H. MuirheadDesertion, admitted, and physical unfitness, notwithstanding the Army’s diagnosis of profound mental deficiency and apparent inability to di1935–1937Committee recommended relief
Anthony Mullen1898–1899ArmyHis mother, without asking him, told the Army he was underage1925–1929Never enacted
John NewmanAdministrative discharge without honor used because a general court-martial was considered impracticable1933–1934Relief enacted
John J. O’ConnorDischarge without honor for an alleged marriage omission the committee found was not knowingly fraudulent1929–1935Committee recommended relief
Charlie R. Pate1901–1902ArmyDischarged without honor in a 1902 order to reduce the size of the Army1926–1928Relief enacted
John F. PattersonInaptitude, inadequate adaptability, allegedly undesirable habits, and an alleged AWOL arising from a mistaken or uncommunicated company tra1934–1935Committee recommended relief
John G. PauleyDischarge without honor for underage enlistment despite later honorable Marine Corps service1926–1927Committee recommended relief
Thompson B. PollardResignation tendered to avoid dismissal for conduct unbecoming after superiors found him illiterate, inefficient, lacking officer-like beari1909–1910Committee recommended relief
Henry PooleDischarge without honor triggered by voluntary marriage disclosure and incomplete or presumed records1934Relief enacted
Alexander M. Proctoralso recorded as A. M. Proctor1875–1878ArmyGave his age as 21 at 20 on the recruiters’ suggestion, then was released at his father’s request1930–1932Vetoed
Clyde Calvin Rhodenbaughalso recorded as Clyde C. Rhodenbaugh, Clyde Rodenbaugh, Calvin Rodenbaugh1898, 1905ArmyDesertion after, by his account, a riding injury and a threatened forced operation1927–1939Never enacted
David F. Richards, alias David RichardsSpecial Order No. 282 implementing the 1902 Army reduction, applied after several minor summary court-martial punishments1930Relief enacted
Daniel F. Roberts1898–1899ArmyA summary court’s mark of “service not honest and faithful,” after a quarrel the committee called an altercation with a noncommissioned officer1926–1928Relief enacted
Virgil W. RobertsFraudulent enlistment based solely on enlisting at age nineteen without parental consent, despite accurately stating his age1930Committee recommended relief
Merle E. RudyAlleged fraudulent enlistment based on supposed concealment of a heart ailment that was discovered only after four Army medical examinations1942Committee recommended relief
Frank C. Russellalso recorded as Frank Russell1899–1901, 1904–1907ArmyDeserted in 1901; discharged without honor for it in 1904, then kept in service1928–1931Relief enacted
Guy Salisburyalso recorded as Guy B. Salisbury, John G. Bowman, Alva J. Zenner1899–1905ArmyA post surgeon’s opinion that he took morphine by mouth1937–1938Relief enacted
Robert Clyde ScottDischarge without honor for alleged fraudulent enlistment despite documented mental incapacity1939Committee recommended relief
Walter M. SeeseeFraudulent enlistment under false pretenses based on minority and consent signed in his mother’s name without her authorization1937Committee recommended relief
Denton L. SimsSubstituted after the War Department admitted his general court-martial lacked jurisdiction and its dishonorable-discharge sentence was void1931Never enacted
Samuel SlisTerm of enlistment expired while serving six months’ confinement at hard labor for drunkenness on guard and leaving his post; the Army then 1930Committee recommended relief
Charles SmithMinority concealed at enlistment; father obtained discharge without Smith’s consent after Smith stated he was 21 when actually 201930Relief enacted
John P. Smith1902 force-reduction discharge without honor with no specific cause preserved1930–1935Committee recommended relief
Charles B. Staffordalso recorded as C. B. Stafford1898ArmyOverstayed a furlough home to his sick mother on his congressman’s word1932–1937Never enacted
George H. Stahl1898ArmySlow to fall in on a land-clearing detail, tried by a court the Army later admitted was void1931–1937Relief enacted
William M. StoddardCourt-martial sentence void because the court was illegally constituted; administrative discharge without honor substituted while larceny ch1931–1934Committee recommended relief
Dennis H. Sullivan1902Army“For the good of the service,” after two $10 court-martial fines1928–1939Never enacted
George H. TaylorDesertion after repeated denial of furlough to visit his dying mother; Taylor later returned voluntarily, but the Army recorded him as appre1939Never enacted
Sylvester S. ThompsonSelected for discharge without honor in a general Army reduction, under an order aimed at soldiers whose service was deemed not honest and faithful, after one early summary-court conviction1929–1930Relief enacted
Virden Thompsonalso recorded as Bert Thompson, James B. King1899; 1900–1903ArmyA guardian’s consent the Army called fraudulent, after his parents asked for his release as a minor1932–1935Relief enacted
David B. Turpel1898–1899ArmyWent home after his wife died; his papers said “character and service fair”1942–1944Relief enacted
Martin Henry Watermanalso recorded as Martin Waterman1890–1891ArmyHis guardian told the Army he had enlisted underage1931–1934Relief enacted
William F. WheelerPresidential dismissal for absence without leave after severe illness during the Peninsula Campaign and collapse during evacuation; the assi1926Committee recommended relief
John H. D. Wherland (aliases Henry Lowell and Harry Lowell)Underage enlistment after stating his age as 21; discharge obtained on his father’s application because the family needed his support1932–1935Committee recommended relief
Charles H. Willettalso recorded as Charles H. Willet1898–1899ArmyDid not tell the Army he was married1934–1935Never enacted
Harvey O. Willis1897–1898ArmyHis company commander’s request, citing drink, which he swore was revenge for refusing to testify as his captain wanted1929–1934Vetoed
Charles E. Wilson1899ArmyNearsightedness the Army knew about when it enlisted him, and a disease1932–1940Never enacted
Charles Y. Wilsonalso recorded as Charles York Wilson1901–1902ArmyServing a court-martial sentence when the Army ordered a cut in its strength1930–1935Never enacted
Mary E. Winterbottom (widow of Harrison T. Winterbottom)also recorded as widow of Harrison T. WinterbottomCompany A, First Eastern Shore Maryland Infantry, was mustered out in 1862 for refusing orders; in 1896 the War Department retroactively tre1903Committee recommended relief
Herman R. WoltmanImprisonment by civil authorities after arrest for highway robbery; held for two and a half months, never tried, and released for lack of ev1924–1927Relief enacted
Eliza A. Wright (widow of Capt. James H. Wright)also recorded as widow of Capt. James H. WrightResignation accepted while under arrest on charges of drunkenness on duty and conduct unbecoming an officer and gentleman; no court-martial 1902Relief enacted
Underage enlistees discharged for age misrepresentation (class-wide)Fraudulent enlistment based solely on a minor’s misrepresentation that he was old enough to enlist1941–1942Committee recommended relief