Skip to main content
ICML The Archive
Printed page Title page of the hearingsPage Title page

Congressional hearingClean text edition

Court-Martial of Maj. Charles W. Penrose, 1907 (S. Doc. No. 402, Part 2)

Affray at Brownsville, Tex., August 13 and 14, 1906. Proceedings of a General Court-Martial convened at Headquarters Department of Texas, San Antonio, Tex., February 4, 1907, in the case of Maj. Charles W. Penrose. Senate Document No. 402, Part 2, 60th Congress, 1st Session

Congress
60th Congress, 1st Session
Hearings held
1908
Printed pages
1,255

Every word of the hearing is searchable. Try administrative discharge or undesirable.

Why these hearings matter

The record of the general court-martial of Maj. Charles W. Penrose, commander at Fort Brown, convened at San Antonio on February 4, 1907.

This edition gives every printed page its own web page, the clean text beside the image of the printed page.

Contents

Hearing days

  1. Headquarters Department of Texas, San Antonio, Tex., February 4, 1907p. 3
  2. Headquarters Department of Texas, San Antonio, Tex., February 5, 1907p. 25
  3. Headquarters Department of Texas, San Antonio, Tex., February 6, 1907p. 47
  4. Headquarters Department of Texas, San Antonio, Tex., February 7, 1907p. 60
  5. Headquarters Department of Texas, San Antonio, Tex., February 8, 1907p. 97
  6. Headquarters Department of Texas, San Antonio, Tex., February 9, 1907p. 121
  7. Headquarters Department of Texas, San Antonio, Tex., February 11, 1907p. 134
  8. Headquarters Department of Texas, San Antonio, Tex., February 12, 1907p. 178
  9. Headquarters Department of Texas, San Antonio, Tex., February 13, 1907p. 191
  10. Headquarters Department of Texas, San Antonio, Tex., February 14, 1907p. 232
  11. Headquarters Department of Texas, San Antonio, Tex., February 15, 1907p. 268
  12. Headquarters Department of Texas, San Antonio, Tex., February 16, 1907p. 299
  13. Headquarters Department of Texas, San Antonio, Tex., February 18, 1907p. 315
  14. Headquarters Department of Texas, San Antonio, Tex., February 19, 1907p. 359
  15. Headquarters Department of Texas, San Antonio, Tex., February 20, 1907p. 406
  16. Headquarters Department of Texas, San Antonio, Tex., February 21, 1907p. 440
  17. Headquarters Department of Texas, San Antonio, Tex., February 22, 1907p. 484
  18. Headquarters Department of Texas, San Antonio, Tex., February 23, 1907p. 501
  19. Headquarters Department of Texas, San Antonio, Tex., February 25, 1907p. 515
  20. Headquarters Department of Texas, San Antonio, Tex., February 26, 1907p. 535
  21. Headquarters Department of Texas, San Antonio, Tex., February 27,1907p. 535
  22. Headquarters Department of Texas, San Antonio, Tex., February 28, 1907p. 576
  23. Headquarters Department of Texas, San Antonio, Tex., March 1,1907p. 621
  24. Headquarters Department of Texas, San Antonio, Tex., March 2, 1907p. 653
  25. Headquarters Department of Texas, San Antonio, Tex., March 4, 1907p. 674
  26. Headquarters Department of Texas, San Antonio, Tex., March 5, 1907p. 707
  27. HEADQUARTERS DEPARTMENT OF TEXAS, San Antonio, Tex., March 6, 1907p. 745
  28. Headquarters Department of Texas, San Antonio, Tex., March 7, 1907p. 760
  29. Headquarters Department of Texas, San Antonio, Tex., March 8, 1907p. 804
  30. Headquarters Department of Texas, San Antonio, Tex., March 9, 1907p. 847
  31. Headquarters Department of Texas, San Antonio, Tex., March 11, 1907p. 856
  32. Headquarters Department of Texas, San Antonio, Tex., March 12,1907p. 893
  33. HEADQUARTERS DEPARTMENT OF TEXAS, San Antonio, Tex., March 13, 1907p. 935
  34. Headquarters Department of Texas, San Antonio, Tex., March 14, 1907p. 968
  35. Headquarters Department of Texas, San Antonio, Tex., March 15, 1907p. 982
  36. Headquarters Department of Texas, San Antonio, Tex., March 16, 1907p. 1029
  37. Headquarters Department of Texas, San Antonio, Tex., March 18, 1907p. 1041
  38. Headquarters Department of Texas, San Antonio, Tex., March 19, 1907p. 1091
  39. Headquarters Department of Texas, San Antonio, Tex., March 20, 1907p. 1129
  40. Headquarters Department of Texas, San Antonio, Tex., March 21, 1907p. 1141
  41. Headquarters Department of Texas, San Antonio, Tex., March 22, 1907p. 1200
  42. Headquarters Department of Texas, San Antonio, Tex., March 23, 1907p. 1221
Full contents 145 entries
  1. AFFRAY AT BROWNSVILLE, TEX. AUGUST 13 AND 14, 1906 PROCEEDINGS OF A GENERAL COURT-MARTIAL CONVENED AT Headquarters Department of Texas San Antonio,...Title page
  2. INDEX.i, Unnumbered b
  3. PROCEEDINGS OF A GENERAL COURT-MARTIAL CONVENED AT HEADQUARTERS DEPARTMENT OF TEXAS, SAN ANTONIO, TEX., BY VIRTUE OF THE FOLLOWING ORDERS:3
  4. SPECIAL ORDERS, No. 264.3
  5. SPECIAL ORDERS, No. 268.3
  6. Headquarters Department of Texas, San Antonio, Tex., February 4, 1907.3
    1. Charge.—Neglect of duty, to the prejudice of good order and military discipline, in violation of the sixty-second article of war.4
    2. Specification I.—4
    3. Specification II.—4
    4. Mr. George W. Rendall, a witness for the prosecution, was duly sworn and testified as follows:6
  7. Headquarters Department of Texas, San Antonio, Tex., February 5, 1907.25
    1. Mrs. George W. Rendall, a witness for the prosecution, was duly sworn and testified as follows:25
    2. Teofilo Martinez, a witness for the prosecution, was duly sworn, and testified as follows:45
  8. Headquarters Department of Texas, San Antonio, Tex., February 6, 1907.47
    1. Mr. J. P. McDonnel, a witness for the prosecution, was duly sworn, and testified as follows:50
    2. Lieut. Roger S. Fitch, First United States Cavalry, a witness for the prosecution, was duly sworn, and testified as follows:50
    3. Colonel Stevens was then duly sworn upon his voir dire.57
    4. Maj. Charles W. Penrose, Twenty-fifth Infantry, was duly sworn.58
    5. Maj. A. P. Blocksom, a witness (requested by the member on voir dire), was duly sworn, and testified as follows:60
  9. Headquarters Department of Texas, San Antonio, Tex., February 7, 1907.60
    1. Mrs. Kate E. Leahy, a witness for the prosecution, was duly sworn, and testified as follows:73
    2. Mr. F. A. H. Sanborn, a witness for the prosecution, was duly sworn, and testified as follows:93
  10. Headquarters Department of Texas, San Antonio, Tex., February 8, 1907.97
    1. Mr. Charles B. Chace, a witness for the prosecution, was duly sworn, and testified as follows:102
    2. Mr. Joe Bodin, a witness for the prosecution, was duly sworn, and testified as follows:108
    3. Mr. M. Y. Dominguez, a witness for the prosecution, was duly sworn, and testified as follows:116
  11. Headquarters Department of Texas, San Antonio, Tex., February 9, 1907.121
    1. Headquarters Department of Texas, San Antonio, Tex., February 11, 1907.134
      1. Mr. F. E. Starck, a witness for the prosecution, was duly sworn, and testified as follows:153
      2. Dr. Frederick J. Combe, mayor of Brownsville, a witness for the prosecution, was duly sworn, and testified as follows:166
    2. Headquarters Department of Texas, San Antonio, Tex., February 12, 1907.178
      1. Headquarters Department of Texas, San Antonio, Tex., February 13, 1907.191
        1. Headquarters Department of Texas, San Antonio, Tex., February 14, 1907.232
          1. R. B. Creager, a witness for the prosecution, was duly sworn and testified as follows:262
        2. Headquarters Department of Texas, San Antonio, Tex., February 15, 1907.268
          1. Headquarters Department of Texas, San Antonio, Tex., February 16, 1907.299
            1. W. F. Dennett, a witness for the prosecution, was duly sworn, and testified as follows:305
          2. Headquarters Department of Texas, San Antonio, Tex., February 18, 1907.315
            1. Mr. L. W. Evans, a witness for the prosecution, was duly sworn and testified as follows:323
            2. A. Littlefield, a witness for the prosecution, was duly sworn and testified as follows:339
            3. THE PENROSE COURT-MARTIAL—Continued. PART 2. FEBRUARY 19, 20, 21, AND 22, 1907.357, Unnumbered a
          3. Headquarters Department of Texas, San Antonio, Tex., February 19, 1907.359
            1. Dr. C. H. Thorn, a witness for the prosecution, was duly sworn, and testified as follows:359
            2. Fred Tate, a witness for the prosecution, was then duly sworn and testified as follows:384
            3. Ygnacio Garza, a witness for the prosecution, being duly sworn, testified as follows:397
          4. Headquarters Department of Texas, San Antonio, Tex., February 20, 1907.406
            1. Mr. N. A. Alanis, a witness for the prosecution, was duly sworn and testified as follows:422
            2. Capt. Dana W. Kilburn, Twenty-sixth United States Infantry, a witness for the prosecution, being duly sworn, testified as follows:427
            3. Lieut. Col. Frank Baker (member of the court), Ordnance Department, U. S. Army, a witness for the prosecution, being duly sworn, testified as follows:432
            4. Felix Valdez Calderon, a witness for the prosecution, being duly sworn, testified as follows:434
          5. Headquarters Department of Texas, San Antonio, Tex., February 21, 1907.440
            1. Mr. Herbert Elkins, a witness for the prosecution, was duly sworn, and testified as follows:442
            2. Leonarda Sanchez, a witness for the prosecution, was duly sworn through an interpreter, and testified as follows:479
          6. Headquarters Department of Texas, San Antonio, Tex., February 22, 1907.484
            1. Second Lieut. George C. Lawrason, Twenty-fifth Infantry, a witness for the prosecution, was duly sworn, and testified as follows:484
            2. THE PENROSE COURT-MARTIAL—Continued. PART 3. FEBRUARY 23, 25, 26, 27, AND 28, 1907.499, Unnumbered a
          7. Headquarters Department of Texas, San Antonio, Tex., February 23, 1907.501
            1. Headquarters Department of Texas, San Antonio, Tex., February 25, 1907.515
              1. E. M. Gebhardt, first sergeant Company F, Twenty-sixth United States Infantry, a witness for the prosecution, being duly sworn, testified as follows:531
              2. Capt. E. A. Macklin, Twenty-fifth United States Infantry, a witness for the prosecution, being duly sworn, testified as follows:533
            2. Headquarters Department of Texas, San Antonio, Tex., February 26, 1907.535
              1. Headquarters Department of Texas, San Antonio, Tex., February 27,1907.535
                1. SPECIAL ORDERS, No. 46. HEADQUARTERS DEPARTMENT OF TEXAS, San Antonio, Tex., February 26, 1907.536
              2. Headquarters Department of Texas, San Antonio, Tex., February 28, 1907.576
                1. Maj. A. P. Blocksom, United States Army, a witness for the prosecution, was duly sworn, and testified as follows:580
                2. Brownsville, Tex., August 29, 1906.594
                3. Headquarters Southwestern Division, Oklahoma City, Okla., September 4, 1906.598
                4. THE PENROSE COURT-MARTIAL—Continued. PART 4. MARCH 1, 2, AND 4, 1907.619, Unnumbered a
              3. Headquarters Department of Texas, San Antonio, Tex., March 1,1907.621
                1. St. Louis, Mo., December 4, 1906. Capt. William Kelly, or Mayor Frederic Combe, Brownsville, Tex.:629
                2. Camp Mabry, Austin, Tex., August 19, 1906. Military Secretary of the Army, Washington, D. C.:637
                3. “Brownsville, Tex., August 19. “Chief of Staff, Camp Mabry, “Austin, Tex.:637
                4. Brownsville, Tex., August 20, 1906. The Military Secretary, United States Army, Washington, D. C.:638
                5. Fort Brown, Tex., August 21, 1906. Chief of Staff, Camp Mabry, Austin Tex.:638
                6. Brownsville, Tex., August 21, 1906. To Chief of Staff, Camp Mabry, Austin, Tex.:638
                7. Fort Brown, Tex., August 23, 1906. The Military Secretary, United States Army, Washington, D. C.:639
                8. Brownsville, Tex., August 28, 1906. Chief of Staff, Camp Mabry, Austin, Tex.:639
              4. Headquarters Department of Texas, San Antonio, Tex., March 2, 1907.653
                1. Headquarters Department of Texas, San Antonio, Tex., March 4, 1907.674
                  1. Washington, D. C., February 26. Capt. Charles E. Hay, Jr., Judge-Advocate, Department of Texas, San Antonio, Tex.:677
                  2. Military Secretary, Washington, D. C.:677
                  3. Washington, D. C., March 2. Capt. Chas. E. Hay, Jr., Acting Judge-Advocate, San Antonio, Tex.:677
                  4. José Martinez, a witness for the prosecution, being duly sworn through the interpreter, testified as follows:699
                  5. THE PENROSE COURT-MARTIAL—Continued. PART 5. MARCH 5, 6, 7, AND 8, 1907.705, Unnumbered a
                2. Headquarters Department of Texas, San Antonio, Tex., March 5, 1907.707
                  1. Second Lieut. H. S. Grier, Twenty-fifth United States Infantry, a witness for the prosecution, was duly sworn and testified as follows:720
                3. HEADQUARTERS DEPARTMENT OF TEXAS, San Antonio, Tex., March 6, 1907.745
                  1. “March 6, 1907. “To The Military Secretary, Washington, D. C.:760
                  2. “Fort Sam Houston, Tex., March 6, 1907. “To The Military Secretary, United States Army, “Washington, D. C.:760
                4. Headquarters Department of Texas, San Antonio, Tex., March 7, 1907.760
                  1. Sergt. Maj. Spottswood W. Taliaferro, Twenty-fifth Infantry, a witness for the defense, was duly sworn, and testified as follows:760
                  2. Rowland Osborn, post quartermaster-sergeant, United States Army, a witness for the accused, was then duly sworn, and testified as follows:796
                5. Headquarters Department of Texas, San Antonio, Tex., March 8, 1907.804
                  1. Washington, D. C., March 7. Capt. Charles E. Hay, Jr., Judge-Advocate, San Antonio, Tex.:804
                  2. Private O. C. West, Company B, Twenty-sixth Infantry, a witness for the defense, was duly sworn and testified as follows:804
                  3. Capt. J. F. Preston, Twenty-sixth Infantry, a witness for the defense, was duly sworn and testified as follows:808
                  4. Capt. H. M. Dichmann, Twenty-sixth Infantry, a witness for the defense, was duly sworn and testified as follows:814
                  5. Mr. O. J. Matlock, a witness for the defense, was duly sworn and testified as follows:819
                  6. Matias G. Tamayo, a witness for the defense, was duly sworn and testified as follows:823
                  7. THE PENROSE COURT-MARTIAL—Continued. PART 6. MARCH 9, 11, AND 12, 1907.846, Unnumbered a
                6. Headquarters Department of Texas, San Antonio, Tex., March 9, 1907.847
                  1. Samuel Wheeler, a witness for the defense, was duly sworn and testified as follows:848
                7. Headquarters Department of Texas, San Antonio, Tex., March 11, 1907.856
                  1. Francois L. Oltmans, first-class sergeant, Hospital Corps, United States Army, a witness for the defense, was duly sworn and testified as follows:887
                8. Headquarters Department of Texas, San Antonio, Tex., March 12,1907.893
                  1. Jacob Frazier, a witness for the defense, was duly sworn, and testified as follows:894
                  2. Mingo Sanders, a witness for the defense, was duly sworn and testified as follows:911
                  3. THE PENROSE COURT-MARTIAL—Continued. PART 7. MARCH 13, 14, AND 15, 1907.934, Unnumbered a
                  4. MEMORANDUM FOR THE SECRETARY OF WAR.935
                9. HEADQUARTERS DEPARTMENT OF TEXAS, San Antonio, Tex., March 13, 1907.935
                  1. Thomas J. Green, a witness for the defense, was duly sworn and testified as follows:935
                10. Headquarters Department of Texas, San Antonio, Tex., March 14, 1907.968
                  1. Newton Carlisle, formerly sergeant of Company C, Twenty-fifth Infantry, a witness for the defense, being duly sworn, testified as follows:978
                11. Headquarters Department of Texas, San Antonio, Tex., March 15, 1907.982
                  1. Washington, D. C., March 14. Capt. Charles E. Hay, Jr., Judge-Advocate, Court-Martial, San Antonio, Tex.:982
                  2. Col. A. H. Stucky, a witness for the defense, was duly sworn, and testified as follows:983
                  3. Lieut. H. A. Wiegenstein, Twenty-fifth Infantry, a witness for the defense, was duly sworn, and testified as follows:989
                  4. Second Lieut. James Blyth, of the Twenty-fifth Infantry, a witness for the defense, was duly sworn, and testified as follows:1011
                  5. THE PENROSE COURT-MARTIAL—Continued. PART 8. MARCH 16, 18, 19, AND 20, 1907.1028, Unnumbered a
                12. Headquarters Department of Texas, San Antonio, Tex., March 16, 1907.1029
                  1. Lieut. R. P. Harbold, Twenty-fifth Infantry, a witness for the defense, was duly sworn and testified as follows:1029
                13. Headquarters Department of Texas, San Antonio, Tex., March 18, 1907.1041
                  1. Alexander Ash, a witness for the defense, was duly sworn and testified as follows:1051
                  2. Joseph H. Howard, a witness for the defense, was duly sworn, and testified as follows:1057
                  3. Capt. Samuel P. Lyon, a witness for the defense, after being duly sworn, testified as follows:1070
                14. Headquarters Department of Texas, San Antonio, Tex., March 19, 1907.1091
                  1. Lieut. Harry G. Leckie, a witness for the defense, upon being duly sworn, testified as follows:1109
                15. Headquarters Department of Texas, San Antonio, Tex., March 20, 1907.1129
                  1. Charles H. Madison, a witness for the defense, was duly sworn, and testified as follows:1132
                  2. THE PENROSE COURT-MARTIAL—Continued. PART 9. MARCH 21, 22, AND 23, 1907. WITH INDEX.1139, Unnumbered a
                16. Headquarters Department of Texas, San Antonio, Tex., March 21, 1907.1141
                  1. Maj. C. J. T. Clarke, Twenty-sixth Infantry, a witness for the defense, was duly sworn and testified as follows:1141
                  2. The Accused, at his own request, was duly sworn as a witness, and testified as follows:1142
                  3. Fort Brown, Tex., August 20, 1906. Capt. William Kelly, Chairman Citizens’ Committee, Brownsville, Tex.1164
                  4. Confidential.] Fort Reno, Okla., September 20, 1906.1166
                  5. Fort Reno, Okla., January 24, 1907. Lieut. Col. L. A. Lovering, Fourth United States Infantry, Acting Inspector-General, Inspector-General, Southwe...1168
                  6. Walker McCurdy, a witness for the prosecution, was called in rebuttal, and, having been sworn, testified as follows:1194
                17. Headquarters Department of Texas, San Antonio, Tex., March 22, 1907.1200
                  1. Capt. H. E. Ely, Twenty-sixth U. S. Infantry, a witness introduced by the prosecution in rebuttal, was duly sworn, and testified as follows:1200
                  2. Judge-Advocate-General, Washington, D. C.1221
                18. Headquarters Department of Texas, San Antonio, Tex., March 23, 1907.1221
                  1. Washington, D. C., March 22. Capt. Charles E. Hay, Jr., Acting Judge-Advocate, Judge-Advocate, Department of Texas, San Antonio, Tex.:1221
                  2. Washington, D. C., March 22. Capt. C. E. Hay, Jr., Acting Judge-Advocate, Judge-Advocate, Department of Texas, San Antonio, Tex.:1221
                  3. The accused, his counsels, the reporter, and the judge-advocate then withdrew, and the court was closed, and finds the accused, Maj. Charles W. Pen...1248
                  4. Headquarters Department of Texas, San Antonio, Tex., March 25, 1907.1248

                Every page

                Senate Document No. 402, Part 2

                Pages 3–52
                Pages 53–102
                Pages 103–152
                Pages 153–202
                Pages 203–252
                Pages 253–302
                Pages 303–352
                Pages 353–403
                Pages 404–453
                Pages 454–504
                Pages 505–554
                Pages 555–604
                Pages 605–655
                Pages 656–705
                Pages 707–756
                Pages 757–806
                Pages 807–856
                Pages 857–906
                Pages 907–956
                Pages 957–1006
                Pages 1007–1056
                Pages 1057–1106
                Pages 1107–1157
                Pages 1158–1207
                Pages 1208–1248

                About this edition

                • The text follows the printed original word for word, with its spelling, punctuation, italics and paragraphing. Nothing is silently corrected. A note explains any doubtful reading.
                • Bracketed words describe what the page shows (a seal, a rule, an illustration) or mark where a witness points to a map or exhibit. Where the printer's own brackets appear, as in [Telegram.], they are kept.
                • The corrected transcription is by Tyson Manker, read page by page against the printed original, with AI systems (OpenAI's ChatGPT and Codex and Anthropic's Claude) assisting under his direction.
                • Corrections are made openly. Each one raises the version number.

                Cite this edition

                Affray at Brownsville, Tex, S. Doc. No. 402, pt. 2, 60th Cong., 1st Sess. (1908) (ICML Clean Text Edition, version 1.2), archive.icml.us/editions/penrose-court-martial-s-doc-402-pt-2-1908/