Page iCongressional hearingClean text edition
Brownsville Court of Inquiry, Volumes I to III (S. Doc. No. 701, 1910)
Report of the Proceedings of the Court of Inquiry Relative to the Shooting Affray at Brownsville, Tex., August 13-14, 1906, by Soldiers of Companies B, C, and D, Twenty-fifth United States Infantry. Senate Document No. 701, 61st Congress, 3d Session, Volumes I to III
- Congress
- 61st Congress, 3d Session
- Hearings held
- December 12, 1910
- Printed pages
- 834
Every word of the hearing is searchable. Try administrative discharge or undesirable.
Why these hearings matter
The first three of the twelve volumes of the Court of Inquiry appointed under the Act of March 3, 1909. The court was to hear all charges and testimony on the Brownsville affray and to determine which of the men discharged without honor under Special Orders No. 266 were qualified to reenlist.
These volumes record the court's review of the Senate testimony and of the men's sworn statements, company by company, and the testimony of its first witnesses.
This edition gives every printed page its own web page, the clean text beside the image of the printed page.
Contents
Hearing days
- WASHINGTON, D. C., May 4, 1909p. 1
- WASHINGTON, D. C., Monday, May 10, 1909p. 2
- WASHINGTON, D. C., Monday, May 17, 1909p. 4
- WASHINGTON, D. C., Monday, May 24, 1909p. 4
- WASHINGTON, D. C., Tuesday, June 1, 1909p. 5
- WASHINGTON, D. C., Monday, June 7, 1909p. 5
- WASHINGTON, D. C., Monday, June 14, 1909p. 6
- WASHINGTON, D. C., Monday, June 21, 1909p. 7
- WASHINGTON, D. C., Monday, June 28, 1909p. 7
- WASHINGTON, D. C., Tuesday, July 6, 1909p. 8
- WASHINGTON, D. C., Monday, July 12, 1909p. 9
- WASHINGTON, D. C., Monday, July 19, 1909p. 10
- WASHINGTON, D. C., Monday, July 26, 1909p. 11
- WASHINGTON, D. C., Monday, August 2, 1909p. 11
- WASHINGTON, D. C., Monday, August 9, 1909p. 12
- WASHINGTON, D. C., Friday, October 1, 1909p. 12
- WASHINGTON, D. C., Monday, October 11, 1909p. 13
- WASHINGTON, D. C., Monday, October 18, 1909p. 14
- WASHINGTON, D. C., Monday, October 25, 1909p. 15
- WASHINGTON, D. C., Monday, November 1, 1909p. 15
- WASHINGTON, D. C., Monday, November 8, 1909p. 16
- WASHINGTON, D. C., Monday, November 15, 1909p. 17
- BROWNSVILLE, TEX., Saturday, November 27, 1909p. 19
- BROWNSVILLE, TEX., Monday, November 29, 1909p. 20
- BROWNSVILLE, TEX., Tuesday, November 30, 1909p. 53
- WASHINGTON, D. C., Thursday, December 9, 1909p. 85
- WASHINGTON, D. C., Friday, December 10, 1909p. 85
- WASHINGTON, D. C., Monday, December 13, 1909p. 86
- WASHINGTON, D. C., Tuesday, December 14, 1909p. 128
- WASHINGTON, D. C., Wednesday, December, 15, 1909p. 163
- WASHINGTON, D. C., Monday, December 20, 1909p. 174
- WASHINGTON, D. C., December 21, 1909p. 197
- WASHINGTON, D. C., December 22, 1909p. 209
- WASHINGTON, D. C., Thursday, December 23, 1909p. 241
- WASHINGTON, D. C., Monday, December 27, 1909p. 271
- WASHINGTON, D. C., Tuesday, December 28, 1909p. 297
- WASHINGTON, D. C., Wednesday, December 29, 1909p. 297
- WASHINGTON, D. C., Tuesday, January 4, 1910p. 298
- WASHINGTON, D. C., Wednesday, January 5, 1909p. 324
- Washington, D. C., Thursday, January 6, 1910p. 363
- WASHINGTON, D. C., Friday, January 7, 1910p. 405
- WASHINGTON, D. C., Saturday, January 8, 1910p. 441
- WASHINGTON, D. C., Monday, January 10, 1909p. 461
- WASHINGTON, D. C., Tuesday, January 11, 1910p. 481
- WASHINGTON, D. C., Wednesday, January 12, 1910p. 506
- WASHINGTON, D. C., Thursday, January 13, 1910p. 554
- WASHINGTON, D. C., Friday, January 14, 1910p. 581
- WASHINGTON, D. C., Saturday, January 15, 1909p. 584
- WASHINGTON, D. C., Monday, January 17, 1910p. 597
- WASHINGTON, D. C., Tuesday, January 18, 1910p. 632
- WASHINGTON, D. C., Wednesday, January 19, 1910p. 681
- WASHINGTON, D. C., Thursday, January 20, 1910p. 691
- WASHINGTON, D. C., Friday, January 21, 1910p. 717
- WASHINGTON, D. C., Saturday, January 22, 1910p. 764
- WASHINGTON, D. C., Monday, January 24, 1910p. 765
Full contents 175 entries
- Volume Ii
- COMPANIES B, C, AND D, TWENTY-FIFTH UNITED STATES INFANTRY REPORT OF THE PROCEEDINGS OF THE COURT OF INQUIRY RELATIVE TO THE SHOOTING AFFRAY AT BRO...i
- [In the Senate of the United States, December 12, 1910.]ii
- INDEX, DAILY PROCEEDINGS VOLS. 1 TO 6, INCLUSIVE.iii
- RECORD OF COURT OF INQUIRY.1
- SPECIAL ORDERS, } WAR DEPARTMENT, No. 79. } Washington, April 7, 1909. EXTRACT.1
- DETAIL FOR THE COURT.1
- WASHINGTON, D. C., May 4, 1909.1
- WASHINGTON, D. C., Monday, May 10, 1909.2
- WASHINGTON, D. C., Monday, May 17, 1909.4
- WASHINGTON, D. C., Monday, May 24, 1909.4
- WASHINGTON, D. C., Tuesday, June 1, 1909.5
- WASHINGTON, D. C., Monday, June 7, 1909.5
- WASHINGTON, D. C., Monday, June 14, 1909.6
- WASHINGTON, D. C., Monday, June 21, 1909.7
- WASHINGTON, D. C., Monday, June 28, 1909.7
- WASHINGTON, D. C., Tuesday, July 6, 1909.8
- WASHINGTON, D. C., Monday, July 12, 1909.9
- WASHINGTON, D. C., Monday, July 19, 1909.10
- WASHINGTON, D. C., Monday, July 26, 1909.11
- WASHINGTON, D. C., Monday, August 2, 1909.11
- WASHINGTON, D. C., Monday, August 9, 1909.12
- WASHINGTON, D. C., Friday, October 1, 1909.12
- WASHINGTON, D. C., Monday, October 11, 1909.13
- WASHINGTON, D. C., Monday, October 18, 1909.14
- WASHINGTON, D. C., Monday, October 25, 1909.15
- WASHINGTON, D. C., Monday, November 1, 1909.15
- WASHINGTON, D. C., Monday, November 8, 1909.16
- WASHINGTON, D. C., Monday, November 15, 1909.17
- BROWNSVILLE, TEX., Saturday, November 27, 1909.19
- BROWNSVILLE, TEX., Monday, November 29, 1909.20
- The recorder then presented Mr. CHARLES BENDER, whom he duly swore as a witness, and who testified as follows:21
- The recorder then presented Mr. WILLIAM L. KEEPERS, whom he duly swore as a witness, and who testified as follows:24
- The recorder then presented Capt. WILLIAM KELLY, whom he duly swore as a witness, and who testified as follows:26
- The recorder then presented Mr. R. B. CREAGER, whom he duly swore as a witness, and who testified as follows:27
- The recorder then presented Maj. F. J. COMBE, whom he duly swore as a witness, and who testified as follows:29
- The recorder then presented Mr. CELEDONIO M. GARZA, whom he duly swore as a witness, and who testified as follows:31
- The recorder then presented Mr. LOUIS KOWALSKI, whom he duly swore as a witness, and who testified as follows:33
- The recorder then presented Mr. F. A. H. SANBORN, whom he duly swore as a witness, and who testified as follows:36
- The recorder then presented Mr. GEORGE W. RENDALL, whom he duly swore as a witness, and who testified as follows:37
- The recorder then presented Mr. YGNACIO GARZA, whom he duly swore as a witness, and who testified as follows:44
- The recorder then presented Mr. LOUIS R. COWEN, whom he duly swore as a witness, and who testified, as follows:45
- BROWNSVILLE, TEX., Tuesday, November 30, 1909.53
- The recorder then presented Mr. CELSO OLIVIERA, whom he duly swore as a witness, and who testified, by interpreter, as follows:53
- The recorder then presented Mr. M. A. SALDANA, whom he duly swore as a witness, and who testified as follows:54
- The recorder then presented Mr. FELIX VALDEZ (CALDERON) whom he duly swore as a witness, and who testified, by interpreter, as fol- lows:55
- The recorder then presented Mr. GEORGE CONNOR, whom he duly swore as a witness, and who testified, as follows:56
- The recorder then presented Mr. JOSE GARZA, whom he duly swore as a witness, and who testified, by interpreter, as follows:57
- The recorder then presented Mr. DIODORO MORELOS, whom he duly swore as a witness, and who testified by interpreter, as follows:58
- The recorder then presented Mr. LOUIS GUTIEREZ, whom he duly swore as a witness, and who testified as follows, by interpreter:60
- The recorder then presented Mr. TEOFILO CRIXELL, whom he duly swore as a witness, and who testified as follows:61
- The recorder then presented Mr. E. K. GOODRICH, whom he duly swore as a witness, and who testified as follows:64
- THE STATE OF TEXAS, County of Cameron.64
- The recorder then presented Mrs. KATIE E. LEAHY, whom he duly swore as a witness, and who testified as follows:64
- The recorder then presented JOHN MOORE (colored), whom he duly swore as a witness, and who testified as follows:65
- The recorder then presented Mr. JAMES K. POWERS, whom he duly swore as a witness, and who testified as follows:67
- The recorder then presented Mrs. J. K. POWERS, whom he duly swore as a witness, and who testified, as follows:70
- The recorder then presented Dr. J. K. COMBE, whom he duly swore as a witness, and who testified as follows:72
- The recorder then presented Mr. MANUEL GARZA, whom he duly swore as a witness, and who testified as follows (by interpreter):77
- The recorder then presented Mrs. ANASTASIA GARCIA, whom he duly swore as a witness, and who testified as follows:77
- The recorder then presented Mrs. J. C. MUSEL, whom he duly swore as a witness, and who testified as follows:79
- The recorder then presented Mrs. MARGARET WALLACE, whom he duly swore as a witness, and who testified as follows:79
- The recorder then presented Mr. JOSE MARTINEZ, whom he duly swore as a witness, and who testified as follows:82
- WASHINGTON, D. C., Thursday, December 9, 1909.85
- WASHINGTON, D. C., Friday, December 10, 1909.85
- WASHINGTON, D. C., Monday, December 13, 1909.86
- Mr. CHARLEY HAIRSTON then presented himself before the court of inquiry.86
- Mr. HOYTT ROBINSON, who was musician of the guard at Fort Brown, Tex., on the night of August 13–14, 1906, then presented him- self to the court.102
- Mr. Ray Burdette, who was corporal of the second relief of the guard on the night of August 13–14, 1906, at Fort Brown, Tex., then presented himsel...107
- Mr. James W. Newton then presented himself to the court.124
- WASHINGTON, D. C., Tuesday, December 14, 1909.128
- WASHINGTON, D. C., Wednesday, December, 15, 1909.163
- WASHINGTON, D. C., Monday, December 20, 1909.174
- WASHINGTON, D. C., December 21, 1909.197
- The recorder then presented Mr. W. G. BALDWIN, whom he duly swore as a witness, and who testified as follows:198
- The recorder then presented Mr. A. H. BALDWIN, whom he duly swore as a witness and who testified as follows:201
- [Seaboard Air Line Railway. S. Davies Warfield, R. Lancaster Williams, and E. C. Duncan, Receivers. ]202
- The recorder then presented Mr. R. H. MOORE, whom he duly swore as a witness, and who testified as follows:208
- WASHINGTON, D. C., December 22, 1909.209
- AFTER RECESS. 2 O’CLOCK P. M.230
- WASHINGTON, D. C., Thursday, December 23, 1909.241
- The recorder then presented Mr. E. C. ARNOLD, whom he duly swore as a witness, and who testified as follows:242
- WASHINGTON, D. C., December 22, 1909. Capt. Charles R. Howland, the recorder, and Gen. A. S. Daggett, and Mr. N. B. Marshall, counsel, agree that t...252
- Mr. SAM BATTLE then presented himself before the court.253
- Mr. Joseph Henry Howard then presented himself before the court.254
- Mr. JOSEPH R. ROGERS then presented himself before the court.256
- 2 O’CLOCK P. M.257
- Volume II270, Unnumbered a
- WASHINGTON, D. C., Monday, December 27, 1909.271
- WASHINGTON, D. C., Tuesday, December 28, 1909.297
- WASHINGTON, D. C., Wednesday, December 29, 1909.297
- WASHINGTON, D. C., Tuesday, January 4, 1910.298
- Mr. GEORGE JOHNSON, who was a private in Company C, Twenty- fifth Infantry, and who was on extra duty in the quartermaster’s department as a teamst...298
- JOHN STREATOR, who was a private of Company C, Twenty-fifth Infantry, and on extra duty in the quartermaster’s department as a teamster August 13–1...300
- The recorder then presented Mr. JOSEPH W. PRICE, whom he duly swore as a witness, and who testified as follows:303
- WILLIAM HARDEN, who was private in Company B, Twenty-fifth Infantry, and whose status was “sick in the post hospital” on the night of August 13–14,...305
- Mr. James Duncan, who was cook of Company D on the night of August 13–14, 1906, then presented himself before the court.306
- ALEXANDER ASH, who was in Company D, Twenty-fifth Infantry, on the night of August 13–14, 1906, and on duty as No. 4 of the first relief on guard,...321
- WASHINGTON, D. C., Wednesday, January 5, 1909.324
- JAMES A. SIMMONS, who was a private in Company C, Twenty- fifth Infantry, and Maj. Penrose’s cook, August 13–14, 1906, then presented himself befor...324
- WILLIE H. MILLER, who was a corporal in Company C, Twenty- fifth Infantry, on the night of August 13–14, 1906, then presented himself before the co...333
- Carolina De Saussure, who was a private of Company B, Twenty- fifth Infantry, and on guard as No. 1, second relief, on the night of August 13, 1906...343
- Edward Lee, who was a private of Company C, Twenty-fifth In- fantry, August 13–14, 1906, then presented himself to the court and was duly sworn as...351
- John Holloman, who was a private of Company B, Twenty-fifth Infantry, August 13–14, 1906, then presented himself to the court and was duly sworn as...357
- Washington, D. C., Thursday, January 6, 1910.363
- AFTER RECESS.391
- WASHINGTON, D. C., Friday, January 7, 1910.405
- The recorder then presented Mr. HERBERT J. BROWNE as witness relative to the confession of Boyd Conyers made to him, whom he duly swore as a witnes...405
- This day personally appeared before me Herbert J. Browne, of Washington, D. C., who, being duly sworn, deposes and says:416
- These articles of agreement, made this 1st day of September, 1908, between Herbert J. Browne and William G. Baldwin, of the first part, and George...418
- AFTER RECESS.433
- WASHINGTON, D. C., Saturday, January 8, 1910.441
- WASHINGTON, D. C., Monday, January 10, 1909.461
- ALONZO HALEY, a private of Company D, Twenty-fifth Infantry, who was on extra duty in the quartermaster’s department as teamster on the 13th and 14...461
- WILLIAM VAN HOOK, who was a private of Company D, Twenty- fifth Infantry, on the 13–14 of August, 1906, then presented himself before the court and...475
- WASHINGTON, D. C., Tuesday, January 11, 1910.481
- WASHINGTON, D. C., Wednesday, January 12, 1910.506
- PERRY CISCO, who was a private of Company C, Twenty-fifth In- fantry, August 13–14, 1906, then presented himself before the court, and was duly swo...506
- ELMER BROWN, who was a private of Company B, Twenty-Fifth Infantry, on the 13–14 of August, 1906, and who was in charge of Maj. Penrose’s stable, t...520
- AFTER RECESS.530
- HENRY W. ARVIN, who was cook of Company C, Twenty-fifth In- fantry, on the night of August 13–14, 1906, then presented himself to the court and was...530
- JAMES E. ARMSTRONG, who was the musician of Company C, Twenty-fifth Infantry, on the night of August 13–14, 1906, then presented himself before the...546
- Volume III553, Unnumbered a
- WASHINGTON, D. C., Thursday, January 13, 1910.554
- WILLIAM MCGUIRE, who was a private of Company C, Twenty- fifth Infantry, on the 13th and 14th of August, 1906, then presented himself before the co...554
- GEORGE W. PERKINS, who was a private of Company C, Twenty- fifth Infantry, on the 13th–14th of August, 1906, then presented him- self before the co...559
- JOSEPH H. GRAY, who was a private of Company C, Twenty-fifth Infantry, on the 13th–14th of August, 1906, then presented himself before the court an...570
- JAMES NEWTON, who was a private of Company D, Twenty-fifth In- fantry, on the 13–14 of August, 1906, then presented himself before the court, and w...576
- WASHINGTON, D. C., Friday, January 14, 1910.581
- WASHINGTON, D. C., Saturday, January 15, 1909.584
- WASHINGTON, D. C., Monday, January 17, 1910.597
- SAMUEL R. HOPKINS, who was a private of Company B, Twenty- fifth Infantry, on the 13–14 of August, 1906, then presented himself before the court, a...607
- JOHN H. HILL, who was a corporal in Company C, Twenty-fifth Infantry, on the 13th and 14th of August, 1906, then presented him- self before the cou...614
- WASHINGTON, D. C., Tuesday, January 18, 1910.632
- GEORGE W. HARRIS, who was a private of Company C, Twenty- fifth Infantry, on the night of 13th–14th of August, 1906, then pre- sented himself befor...632
- ROBERT TURNER, who was a private of Company C, on the 13–14 of August, 1906, then presented himself before the court and was duly sworn as a witnes...637
- ROBERT WILLIAMS, who was a private in Company D, Twenty-fifth Infantry, on the 13–14 of August, 1906, then presented himself before the court, and...643
- JOSEPH JONES, who was a musician in Company D, on the 13th and 14th of August, 1906, then presented himself before the court, and was duly sworn as...649
- CHARLES JONES, who was a private in Company D, Twenty-fifth Infantry, on the 13th and 14th of August, 1906, then presented him- self before the cou...657
- CHARLES H. HAWKINS, who was a corporal in Company D, Twenty- fifth Infantry, on the 13th and 14th of August, 1906, then presented himself before th...664
- JOHN GREEN, who was a private of Company D, Twenty-fifth Infantry, on the night of August 13 and 14, 1906, then presented himself before the court...670
- STROWDER DARNELL, who was a private in Company D on the 13th and 14th of August, 1906, then presented himself before the court, and was duly sworn...676
- WASHINGTON, D. C., Wednesday, January 19, 1910.681
- WASHINGTON, D. C., Thursday, January 20, 1910.691
- GEORGE W. HALL, who was a private in Company D, Twenty-fifth Infantry, on the 13th and 14th of August, 1906, then presented him- self before the co...692
- WALTER BANKS, who was a musician of Company C, Twenty-fifth Infantry, on the night of the 13th–14th of August, 1906, then pre- sented himself befor...696
- WILLIAM BROWN, who was a private in Company B, Twenty-fifth Infantry, on the 13th and 14th of August, 1906, then presented him- self before the cou...710
- WASHINGTON, D. C., Friday, January 21, 1910.717
- GEORGE W. NEWTON, who was artificer of Company D, Twenty-fifth Infantry, then presented himself before the court, and was duly sworn as a witness b...717
- SAMUEL E. SCOTT, who was a private in Company D, Twenty-fifth Infantry, on the night of August 13–14, 1906, then presented himself before the court...739
- AFTER RECESS.748
- WASHINGTON, D. C., Saturday, January 22, 1910.764
- WASHINGTON, D. C., Monday, January 24, 1910.765
- WILLIAM E. JONES, who was a private in Company D, Twenty-fifth Infantry, on the 13th and 14th of August, 1906, then presented him- self before the...765
- MARK GARMAN, who was a private in Company C, Twenty-fifth Infantry on the 13th and 14th of August, 1906, then presented him- self before the court...780
- Mr. LAERTIS WEBB, who was a private in Company C, Twenty-fifth Infantry, on the 13th–14th of August, 1906, then presented himself before the court...785
- JAMES JOHNSON, who was a private in Company B, Twenty-fifth Infantry on the night of August 13–14, 1906, then presented himself to the court and wa...798
Every page
Pages
Volume I
Pages 1–50
Pages 51–100
Pages 101–150
Pages 151–200
Pages 201–250
Volume II
Pages 271–320
Pages 321–370
Pages 371–420
Pages 421–470
Pages 471–520
Volume III
Pages 554–603
Pages 604–653
Pages 654–703
Pages 704–753
Pages 754–803
About this edition
- The text follows the printed original word for word, with its spelling, punctuation, italics and paragraphing. Nothing is silently corrected. An error in the original is kept and marked [sic], and a note explains any doubtful reading.
- Words the printer broke across lines are joined.
- Every page is read against its image by a transcriber and again by a second reader. The transcribers and readers are AI systems, OpenAI's ChatGPT and Codex and Anthropic's Claude, working under the Institute's direction. Doubtful readings are settled by Tyson Manker against the page image.
- Corrections are made openly. Each one raises the version number.
Cite this edition
Proceedings of the Court of Inquiry Relative to the Shooting Affray at Brownsville, Tex., S. Doc. No. 701, 61st Cong., 3d Sess. (1910) (ICML Clean Text Edition, version 1.0), archive.icml.us/editions/brownsville-court-of-inquiry-vols-1-3-1910/